Three Numbers That Should Not Be the Same
A services firm has three different numbers describing the same month, and in a surprising number of firms all three are treated as one.
Time recorded is what the team did. Work billed is what went out on invoices. Cash received is what arrived in the bank. In a product business these move together closely enough that conflating them is survivable. In a services business they routinely diverge by weeks, and sometimes the divergence is the whole story of the month.
A client pays a retainer in advance: cash received, nothing earned. A team works three weeks on a milestone that invoices next month: work performed, nothing billed. A project overruns and the extra days are absorbed: time recorded, never billable at all.
Firms that treat receipts as revenue get a profit figure that moves with billing timing rather than with performance, and a project margin they only learn after the project closes, which is precisely when it is too late to do anything about it.
This article covers how to handle retainers, what work in progress and unbilled revenue actually mean, what each billing model demands of the setup, and how to see project margin while the project is still running. It is written for finance managers, CFOs and practice leads.
The Business Problem: Cash Mistaken for Performance
- Retainers are recognised when received. The money arrives, it is posted as revenue, and the obligation to deliver against it sits nowhere in the accounts.
- Unbilled work is invisible. Time recorded against a project that has not yet been invoiced does not appear anywhere, so the balance sheet understates what the firm is owed and the profit figure understates the month.
- Revenue moves with invoicing convenience. A month where somebody got the billing out looks better than a month where they did not, and neither tells you about performance.
- Project margin arrives late. Profitability is calculated when the project closes, from timesheets and invoices reconciled by hand. By then the next three projects have been scoped on the same assumptions.
- Write-offs are absorbed silently. Time that cannot be billed (overrun, rework, goodwill) is simply not invoiced, and never appears as a number anyone sees.
- Scope creep has no financial trace. Extra work agreed informally gets delivered and absorbed, and the only record is that the project made less than expected.
- Different people handle it differently. Without a stated policy, each project manager invoices on their own rhythm, which makes month-to-month comparison meaningless.
What the Confusion Costs
- Pricing repeats its mistakes. A firm that learns project margin after the fact scopes the next engagement on the same assumptions that lost money on the last one.
- Revenue is misstated by period. Both ways: overstated where retainers are taken on receipt, understated where unbilled work is ignored. For a firm with any external reporting obligation, this is a problem independent of the management question.
- Working capital is misread. Unbilled work is money owed to you that is not in receivables and not on the balance sheet. A firm with substantial WIP and no visibility of it consistently understates its own position.
- Utilisation and realisation get conflated. A team can be fully utilised and the firm still lose money, if what they worked on was not billable. Without the distinction, a busy team is assumed to be a profitable one.
- Partners cannot intervene. The value of knowing a project is going wrong is entirely in how early you know. Month four is useful; after closure is history.
- Audit difficulty at year end. Explaining revenue recognition on retainers and long-running engagements, from a system that does not distinguish them, is a slow and expensive conversation.
Retainers: Money You Hold, Not Money You Have Earned
The most common error in services finance, and the easiest to fix.
A retainer received in advance is a liability. You hold the clientβs money against work you have not yet performed. Until you perform it, it is deferred income, not revenue.
Recognise it as the work is delivered. Each period, the portion earned moves from the liability to revenue. What remains is what you still owe in service.
That unearned balance is a management number, not just an accounting one. It tells you how much delivery obligation is sitting ahead of you, which matters for capacity planning as much as for reporting.
Different retainer types behave differently, and the distinction should be deliberate:
- A pure advance against work to be specified later: a straightforward liability drawn down as work occurs.
- A monthly fee for availability, whether or not work is requested: usually earned in the period regardless, because availability is the service.
- A block of hours purchased upfront: earned as hours are consumed, with a policy on what happens to unused hours at expiry.
Decide the expiry treatment in advance. Unused hours at the end of a retainer period: do they expire, roll over, or become refundable? This is a contractual question with an accounting consequence, and firms that have not settled it discover the ambiguity during a client dispute.
Confirm the treatment with your accountant. Revenue recognition on service contracts is a standards question (under IFRS, the governing standard is IFRS 15), and the right answer depends on the contract terms and your jurisdiction. This article describes the shape of it; it is not accounting advice.
Work in Progress and Unbilled Revenue
The mirror image of the retainer problem, and the one most firms never address at all.
- Work performed but not yet invoiced is value you have created. Three weeks of delivery on a milestone that bills next month is revenue earned this month under accrual accounting, and an asset on the balance sheet.
- Firms ignore it because it is harder. It requires time to be recorded accurately and promptly, a view of what is billable, and a policy on what gets recognised. None of that is difficult; all of it requires discipline.
- The minimum viable version: at each period end, value the time recorded against open projects that has not been invoiced, at the rate it will be billed at, less anything you already know will be written off. That is your unbilled position. Even approximately, it is far better than treating it as zero.
- Be conservative and consistent. The risk in recognising unbilled revenue is recognising work that will never be billed. A policy that excludes time on projects already over budget, or applies a realisation assumption, protects against that, and consistency matters more than precision.
- Separate unbilled from overdue. They are different things. Unbilled work has not been invoiced yet. Overdue invoices have been issued and not paid. Firms that lump them together as βowed to usβ cannot manage either.
- Track the ageing of unbilled work. Time sitting unbilled for two months is a question: is it a billing delay, a dispute, or work that was never going to be billable? Each has a different answer and the ageing is what surfaces it.
Billing Models and What Each Demands
Each model has a different relationship between work and revenue, and the setup has to reflect the one you actually use.
Time and Materials
The simplest relationship: time recorded is revenue earned, at agreed rates. Demands accurate, prompt time recording, since the timesheet is the invoice. The main leakage is unrecorded time, which is revenue that silently never existed.
Fixed Price
Revenue is earned as the work is performed, not as cash arrives or as milestones happen to be invoiced. This requires some view of completion, commonly effort incurred against total expected effort. The main risk is that the denominator moves: when the estimate to complete grows, both margin and the recognised position change, and finding that out late is how fixed-price work loses money.
Retainer
As above: a liability drawn down as service is delivered, with the treatment depending on what the retainer actually buys.
Milestone Billing
Invoicing is triggered by deliverables, which is a cash timing arrangement rather than a revenue recognition method. Work performed between milestones is unbilled revenue, and firms that recognise only at milestones report lumpy revenue that has nothing to do with activity.
Capped Time and Materials
The common hybrid, and the one that causes most difficulty: billed as time and materials up to a ceiling. The hours beyond the cap are recorded, unbillable and frequently invisible, which makes the cap look harmless when it is where the margin went.
A firm usually runs several of these at once, which is fine provided each project is coded to its model and the policy for each is written down. What does not work is a single approach applied to all of them.
Project Margin While the Project Is Running
This is the output that changes behaviour, and it depends on everything above being in place.
- The components. Revenue earned to date, cost of delivery to date (people at cost, not at charge-out) plus any direct expenses, giving margin as it stands rather than as it was budgeted.
- Cost rates matter and are usually wrong. A charge-out rate is a price. A cost rate is what the person costs the firm, including employment cost and a reasonable overhead allocation. Margin calculated against charge-out rates is not margin.
- Report against the estimate to complete, not just against budget. Budget is what you expected to spend. Estimate to complete is what you now believe it will take. The gap between those two, discovered in month two, is actionable. Discovered at closure, it is a lesson.
- Watch realisation as well as utilisation. Utilisation says how much of available time was used. Realisation says how much of it was billable at full value. A team at high utilisation and poor realisation is busy and unprofitable, and the two numbers together say something neither says alone.
- Make scope changes visible financially. Additional work agreed informally and absorbed is margin leaving the project without a record. Even where you choose to absorb it, recording it as absorbed scope converts an invisible loss into a number you can see across projects.
- Give project managers their own view. A margin report that only finance sees is a reporting exercise. The people who can change the outcome need to see it while they can still act.
Designing the Setup
- Decide the revenue recognition policy per billing model first, with your accountant, before configuring anything. This is the step that determines whether the rest works.
- Set cost rates alongside charge-out rates. Without cost rates there is no margin, only revenue. Agree how overhead is allocated and keep it simple enough to maintain.
- Make project coding mandatory on time and on expense. Time recorded to no project is time you cannot attribute, and expenses coded to overhead that belonged to a project overstate that projectβs margin.
- Get time recorded promptly, not accurately-in-retrospect. A week-old timesheet reconstructed from memory is both less accurate and less useful than a daily one. This is a management discipline question rather than a system one, and it is the most common point of failure.
- Connect delivery to finance. Where project delivery and accounting sit in separate systems, the link between time recorded and revenue recognised is where errors live. Zoho Books and Zoho Projects are designed to work together for exactly this, and confirming what that integration covers for your edition is worth doing before design rather than after.
- Define write-off authority. Who can decide that time will not be billed, and at what value. Without this, write-offs happen at project manager discretion and never appear as a number.
- Agree the period-end routine. What gets valued, by whom, by when. Unbilled revenue that is calculated when someone has time is unbilled revenue that is not reported.
Approaches Compared
| Consideration | Cash-basis thinking | Invoices only | Accrual with WIP and deferred income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retainers | Revenue on receipt | Revenue on receipt | Liability, released as earned |
| Unbilled work | Invisible | Invisible | Recognised and valued |
| Revenue by period | Follows cash | Follows invoicing timing | Follows performance |
| Project margin | After closure | After closure | While running |
| Balance sheet completeness | Understates assets and liabilities | Understates both | Reflects both |
| Effort | Minimal | Low | Moderate, concentrated at period end |
| Requires accurate time recording | No | Partly | Yes |
| Best for | Very small firms with simple arrangements | Firms billing promptly on completion | Any firm with retainers, fixed price or long engagements |
Best Practices
- Treat retainers received in advance as a liability, released to revenue as the service is delivered.
- Decide retainer expiry treatment contractually, because it has an accounting consequence.
- Value unbilled work at every period end, conservatively and consistently, even if approximately.
- Separate unbilled from overdue: they are different problems with different owners.
- Age your unbilled balance and ask why anything over a month old has not been invoiced.
- Set cost rates as well as charge-out rates, or you are reporting revenue rather than margin.
- Make project coding mandatory on time and expense.
- Report against estimate to complete, not only against original budget.
- Track realisation alongside utilisation. Busy and unprofitable is a real and common state.
- Give project managers their own margin view while they can still change the outcome.
Common Mistakes
- Recognising retainers on receipt. The most common error in services finance, and the easiest to correct.
- Treating unbilled work as zero. Understates revenue, understates assets, and hides billing delays.
- Calculating margin against charge-out rates. That is not margin; it is a discount analysis.
- Measuring utilisation alone. A fully utilised team on unbillable work is the exact failure the number conceals.
- Letting each project manager bill on their own rhythm. Makes month-to-month comparison meaningless.
- Absorbing scope changes without recording them. Invisible margin loss, repeated across projects.
- Write-offs at individual discretion with no threshold. The number never becomes visible and therefore never gets managed.
- Recognising unbilled revenue on projects already over budget. Recognising work that will not be billed, which is the one genuine risk in this area.
- Leaving period-end valuation to whoever has time. It will not happen consistently, and inconsistent is worse than approximate.
- Designing the system before agreeing the recognition policy. The policy determines the configuration, not the reverse.
An Illustrative Scenario: A 40-Person Consultancy
The following is a composite illustration drawn from patterns common to professional services firms. It is not an account of a specific Techvaria client, and no figures below come from any real engagement.
Consider a forty-person consultancy running a mix of fixed-price projects, time and materials work, and a handful of monthly retainers.
The Trigger
A quarter that looked poor and had not felt poor. Investigating it, the finance manager found that two large retainer receipts had landed in the previous quarter and a major milestone had invoiced after the quarter end. Activity had been steady; the reported numbers had moved entirely on billing timing.
What the Review Found
Retainers were posted to revenue on receipt, with no deferred income balance anywhere. Unbilled work was not valued at all, so any work performed between milestones simply did not exist in the accounts until invoiced.
Cost rates had never been set. Project profitability, where it was calculated, compared revenue against charge-out value of time, which the finance manager acknowledged was not margin.
Write-offs happened at project manager discretion with no threshold and no record. Nobody could state how much time had been written off in the year.
And capped time and materials engagements (about a quarter of the book) were where the firm suspected it was losing money, without being able to show it.
What Was Implemented
The recognition policy first, agreed with their accountant and written down per billing model. This took two meetings and settled several questions that had been handled differently by different people for years.
Retainers moved to deferred income, released as service was delivered, with expiry treatment confirmed against the actual contract wording, which turned out to differ between two clients in a way nobody had noticed.
Unbilled work was valued at each month end using a deliberately simple and conservative rule, excluding time on projects already over their estimate. The finance manager described the first monthβs figure as βlarger than anyone expectedβ, which was the point.
Cost rates were set, with a simple overhead allocation agreed as good enough rather than precise. Project margin became a monthly report visible to project managers, not just to finance.
A write-off threshold was introduced (below a value, project manager discretion; above it, a partner decision) and write-offs became a reported number.
What Caught Them Out
Time recording discipline. The system was ready well before the behaviour was, and two reminders from a partner were needed before timesheets were reliably current. The finance manager was clear that the configuration had been the easy half.
After Two Quarters
Reported revenue began tracking activity rather than invoicing timing, which made the quarterly numbers both less dramatic and more useful.
The finding that changed decisions was the capped time and materials analysis. Once unbillable hours beyond the cap were visible as a number rather than an impression, the firm could see which engagements were absorbing them and repriced two client arrangements at renewal.
Industry Use Cases
- Consultancies and advisory firms. The core case: mixed billing models, retainers and long engagements. See professional services, and our guide to Zoho Projects and Zoho CRM for professional services firms.
- IT services and software firms. Fixed-price delivery with estimate-to-complete volatility, where the denominator moving is the main margin risk. See IT services and ERP.
- Engineering and design practices. Long projects with milestone billing, where unbilled work between milestones is a substantial and usually invisible balance. See construction.
- Marketing and creative agencies. Retainer-heavy with frequent informal scope expansion, which makes absorbed-scope recording unusually valuable. See professional services.
- Accounting and advisory practices. Repeating compliance engagements alongside advisory work, where realisation rather than utilisation is the number that matters. See Zoho Books implementation, and our Zoho Practice guide for accounting firms.
Frequently Asked Questions
As a liability (deferred income) released to revenue as the service is delivered. It is the clientβs money held against work not yet performed. The unearned balance is also useful operationally, because it tells you how much delivery obligation sits ahead of you. Confirm the specific treatment with your accountant, since it depends on what the retainer contractually buys.
Work performed but not yet invoiced. Under accrual accounting it is revenue earned in the period of performance and an asset on the balance sheet. Firms frequently treat it as zero, which understates both revenue and assets. The minimum viable approach is to value unbilled time on open projects at billing rates at each period end, conservatively and consistently.
A conservative policy (commonly excluding time on projects already over their estimate, or applying a realisation assumption) plus ageing the unbilled balance so that anything sitting for more than a month gets questioned. Consistency matters more than precision here.
Most often because it is calculated against charge-out rates rather than cost rates. A charge-out rate is a price; margin requires what the person actually costs the firm, including employment cost and an overhead allocation. Without cost rates you are reporting revenue, not margin.
Utilisation is how much of available time was used. Realisation is how much of that was billable at full value. A team can be fully utilised and unprofitable if the work was not billable, which is precisely the situation utilisation alone conceals. Report both.
They are designed to, and the link between time recorded in delivery and revenue recognised in finance is exactly where errors occur when the two sit apart. Confirm what the integration covers for your edition before designing around it rather than afterwards.
With the revenue recognition policy per billing model, agreed with your accountant and written down. It determines the configuration rather than the reverse, and in most firms it also settles several questions that different people have been answering differently for years.
Conclusion
Time recorded, work billed and cash received are three different numbers, and a services firm that treats them as one gets a profit figure driven by billing timing rather than by performance.
Two corrections do most of the work. Retainers received in advance are a liability released as the service is delivered, not revenue on receipt: the most common error in services finance and the easiest to fix. And work performed but not yet invoiced is revenue earned and an asset held, valued conservatively and consistently at each period end rather than treated as zero.
After that it is margin. Set cost rates as well as charge-out rates, because without them you are reporting revenue. Report against estimate to complete rather than original budget, so the gap is actionable rather than historical. Track realisation alongside utilisation, since a busy team and a profitable team are not the same thing. And put the margin report in front of project managers while they can still change the outcome.
Start with the recognition policy, agreed per billing model with your accountant and written down. It determines everything that follows, and in most firms, writing it down settles a set of questions that different people have quietly been answering differently for years.
Get Your Services Finances Straight
Techvaria is a Zoho Premium Partner with more than 350 implementations delivered since 2016, from offices in Bangalore, Ahmedabad and Dubai.
A services finance review produces a revenue recognition policy drafted per billing model and ready to take to your accountant, your current retainer balances restated as deferred income, a first valuation of your unbilled position (usually larger than firms expect) and a project margin report built on real cost rates rather than charge-out value.
If a recent quarter looked different from how it felt, that discrepancy is the fastest way to scope this.
Talk to our Zoho consultants, or see how we approach Zoho Books work.
Get Your Services Finances Straight

Director @ Techvaria | Solutions Architect | Low-Code & AI Automation for Growth | Proven Expertise in Digital Transformation Across Industries
